You are here

Positive people sick of negative people leaving mean, pointless reviews/comments

Is anyone else sick and tired of negative people leaving nasty, rude pointless reviews and comments all the time?  I have been using VegWeb for a long time, around 3 years, but only became a member a little while ago, and I have noticed over time that the same mean people keep leaving opinions and comments that no one wants to hear. 

It is one thing to leave a bad review for a recipe - when a recipe doesn't work for you, its a great idea to let people know why it didn't work for you and the changes that you made to the recipe for it not to work, that way they won't make the same mistakes.  It is totally possible to leave an honest but polite 'bad' review that doesn't hurt the feelings of the person that posted the recipe, or turn anyone else off making the recipe. 

However, it is another thing to come along and leave reviews that are mean and hurtful, especially when they have nothing to do with the recipe itself and are just a personal attack on the people who write or review the recipes. 

It is always the same few people who do this, today has been a particularly bad day for these types of reviews and that's what prompted me to post this discussion. 

The most common negative messages that I have seen are some particular 'holier than thou' VegWebbers who go into recipes that they never intend on cooking, usually for cakes, desserts, etc, and leave reviews that the recipe is just crap because it has sugar, flour, oil, etc in it and that it's just junk food and that THEY wouldn't eat it because THEY are so pure and fabulous and only eat pure fabulous things.  I don't understand why they review recipes that they will never cook anyway just so they can share their negativity and spiteful comments.  The hardest thing about being a vegan sometimes is trying to find yummy alternatives for things we used to love, so when someone comes up with a great recipe for some naughty pie or cake or cookie, it is an absolute Godsend!  When someone comes along and chastises everyone for eating 'junk food', frankly it just makes us all feel like crap!  Why should we feel bad for eating something 'naughty' every now and then?  As long as we eat properly most of the time, then we are all entitled to treats!  I say, BRING ON THE CHOCOLATE CAKE!  :D

The reason we are all members of VegWeb is because we are part of a minority group in society who have decided to stop eating animals and animal by-products for the welfare of animals and for our health and wellbeing.  Being a vegan or vegetarian is hard work because people who don't choose this lifestyle have trouble understanding why we choose to go down this path.  It takes a lot of patience to continually explain to people why you don't eat meat or animal products without being 'preachy'.  That's why we all need to stick together.  Whether you're vegetarian, vegan, a raw foodist, fruitarian, WHATEVER, we need to support each other and respect each other's ideas and opinions without getting rude and nasty if your opinion differs. 

Now that I've got all the negatives out, I can focus on the positives.  There are some awesome VegWebbers who always stick up for other people who have had their recipes and reviews attacked.  Thank you for having the courage to stand up to these bullies!  There are people on here who's posts and reviews I absolutely love to read, who contribute so much to the site in the form of recipes, posts, photos, ideas........I truly value and appreciate your contributions to VegWeb, and love trying your recipes, reading your reviews and looking at your fab photos, there are so many inspiring people on here who make being vegan just that little bit easier!!  ;)b

PHEW!!!  Feels good to get that all out in the open. 

HAVE A FABULOUS DAY!!!  :-*

You're right, JKL. If something really doesn't work, we need to know. Otherwise,  it could become a case of, "But the Emperor is not wearing any clothes..." if everyone only ever leaves nicey-nicey reviews.

I've had the experience myself where I iron-cheffed something that I thought was great the first time I ate it. The second, not so much. Maybe I was really hungry when I made it the first time, or just more accepting of the new fudz. But later I had to admit to myself that  my "wonderful" recipe was just....meh. Now, if a recipe you make up sticks in the mind of the person you made it for months later (like my Amazing Asparagus Salad did, to my surprise, in the mind of the person who was there when I invented it) you're onto something special.

0 likes

I feel like a dick all the sudden.  I posted this tonight:

I followed the recipe exactly, but the batter was SUPER dry and crumbly.  I had to mash them together to form them, and when I baked them, they came out looking raw, they never got  golden brown.   They were pretty good, taste wise, but I will continue the search for a great vegan chocolate chip cookie.  Sorry to be  negative.    :-\

about the Happy vegan chocolate chip cookies.  How timely.  I suck.

Sorry you guys.  I guess I'm part of the problem!

I think everyone who has made those before knows to add more liquid maybe...that's what I always do, and they are awesome!

0 likes

karma free kitchen - you're definitely not a dick (nice use of that word though :))  Your review may be slightly negative, but at least you tried the recipe rather than slating it without trying it or even attempting to.

0 likes

and seriously, do desserts have to be good for you?????? 

I think she is gone now, except for her recipes......and if any of you fools try to steal them, she will get all namaste on your ass!

0 likes

i don't mind lots of straight up rave reviews if the person really means it, i'm always suspicious when a recipe has 5 stars and no reviews.. i wish the ppl would tell us why it was so great!

0 likes

and seriously, do desserts have to be good for you?????? 

I think she is gone now, except for her recipes......and if any of you fools try to steal them, she will get all namaste on your ass!

HEE HEE HEE HEE HEE HEE HEE!!!!  :-D :-D :-D  That is hilarious!!!!!!

0 likes

I feel MUCH better now.

Thanks vegweb!

0 likes

Just curious.....has anyone tried any of her recipes?

0 likes

Just curious.....has anyone tried any of her recipes?

I'm nowhere near pure enough, inside or out.
And they say you are what you eat. If that's what caused it...no thank you.  :-D

0 likes

Just curious.....has anyone tried any of her recipes?

I'm nowhere near pure enough, inside or out.
And they say you are what you eat. If that's what caused it...no thank you.  :-D

;D :-D :D

0 likes

if being pure turns you like that......no thanks!

namaste!!!!

0 likes

Just curious.....has anyone tried any of her recipes?

didn't you see that I made her raw coco puffs at a festival and called them my own and made loads of money off of them??!! ::)

0 likes

Just curious.....has anyone tried any of her recipes?

didn't you see that I made her raw coco puffs at a festival and called them my own and made loads of money off of them??!! ::)

i did see that, i bet she did too... and you know - we havent heard from her in awhile so maybe she's roadtripping out to kick your ass.  watch yer back!

0 likes

hm... I found some of those reviews, but it looks like some of them may have been deleted or something (only 2 recent ones like that). Just as well, I guess. But now I'm starting to wonder what's wrong with plain ole table salt  ???

On the flip side, I kinda get annoyed when an unusual recipe has 5 stars and 20 reviews, all saying "i can't wait to make this!" or something, when I'm hoping to find out of the recipe actually worked.

0 likes

ha yeah and the people that are like "it's in the oven now.. ill post the results when it's done!!"

and then never do.

i worry!  did they choke on it?  did it morph into poison and kill them??  i must know!

0 likes

ha yeah and the people that are like "it's in the oven now.. ill post the results when it's done!!"

and then never do.

i worry!  did they choke on it?  did it morph into poison and kill them??  i must know!

haha, that too!

0 likes

ha yeah and the people that are like "it's in the oven now.. ill post the results when it's done!!"

and then never do.

i worry!  did they choke on it?  did it morph into poison and kill them??  i must know!

:lol: Yeah.

0 likes

they died from all the sugar and flour

0 likes

they died from all the sugar and flour

exactly! the poor saps.

0 likes

I found this 'review' midly amusing!!

0 likes

Pages

Log in or register to post comments