You are here

what to make with leftover cookie dough?

I made way too much dough for the sugar cookies my family decorated at Christmas.  It's sitting in my freezer and I really don't want to just eat it all frozen immediately.  (Okay, I want to, but I also want my jeans to still fit next week.) 

Has anyone found anything interesting to do with a bunch of dough other than make more cookies?  I'd like to try making cookie dough ice cream, but I don't have an ice cream maker.  I want to make something I can give away, so someone else's thighs can take the hit.  >:D

Ideas?

mmm cookie dough ice cream sounds awesome.  do you have a vitamix or ice cream maker? 

0 likes

lol, Kelsi, she said she doesn't have an ice cream maker, silly!
Your teeth are still in the wanting yummy soft foods mode. ;)
oooh cookie dough pie crust? Never had it, sounds amazing.

0 likes

Or, you could make a giant cookie...and decorate it...and such.

0 likes

use it as a base for a cookie bar type thing, layer it up with nuts, chocolate, oatmeal.. etc.

i wonder if you added a bunch of soymilk to it you could use it as muffin or pancake batter? 

0 likes

Send it to me  ;)b

0 likes

Or, you could make a giant cookie...and decorate it...and such.

This.  Giant cookies > ordinary cookies.

0 likes

You could shape it into "baskets", bake and fill with icecream and fresh fruit.

Or roll it into cookie-sized tubular shapes with waxed paper, and freeze to use later. Thaw just enough to slice when you want some cookies without having to make the dough, and bake.

0 likes

What if you took the frozen dough cut it into small pieces and stirred it into store bought vanilla so delicious (or other). You be make it like a vegan Cold Stone ;). I love cookie dough ice cream. Yum

0 likes

What if you took the frozen dough cut it into small pieces and stirred it into store bought vanilla so delicious (or other). You be make it like a vegan Cold Stone ;). I love cookie dough ice cream. Yum

we have a winner!

0 likes

lol, Kelsi, she said she doesn't have an ice cream maker, silly!
Your teeth are still in the wanting yummy soft foods mode. ;)
oooh cookie dough pie crust? Never had it, sounds amazing.

oh haha.  whoops!  my mind is definitely on ice cream.  : )

0 likes

Just EAT IT.  ;)b

0 likes

Just EAT IT.  ;)b

....eat it..eat it...eat it..eat it..

0 likes

DO IT! Go go go!

Ha ha. Inside jokes.

0 likes

DO IT! Go go go!

Ha ha. Inside jokes.

Ack!  I'm trying so hard *not* to eat it.  You guys aren't helping!  Okay... maybe I will eat just a really small amount of it... but then I'm going to make it into something - I love the crust idea!

0 likes

My aunt makes a dessert pizza with a sugar cookie crust. Just make a giant cookie and top it with strawberry jam for the sauce, coconut for the "cheeze", and cut fruit roll-ups into toppings like pepperoni (red roll-up) and bell pepper (green roll-up). It's super fun to make and kids especially love it. Sometimes she spreads a vegan cream cheese frosting on top and covers it with fruit which it my favorite dessert pizza.

0 likes
Log in or register to post comments